Connect with H&H

Birch tree dilemma

smoodgie's picture
smoodgie

I have a tree dilemma and I'm not sure what I should do. I really want a clumping birch tree in our front yard. The owner of the nursery that I go to recommended a Whitespire Birch. So, I went to the nursery on Saturday in search of a clumping Whitespire. Turns out that the three they had gotten in recently have already been sold :( So, I decided to by a single-trunk Whitespire instead. It's a lovely tree -- probably between 15-20 feet high, which gives it a jump on catching up to the huge trees in our neighbourhood!!

But...... I still REALLY want a clump birch!! So I contacted the nursery owner and asked him if he'll be ordering in anymore clumping Whitespires. He said that he probably won't be ordering any more this year. When you get large trees late in the season, they're much more stressed and are therefore more susceptible to insect damage. It's safer to only order them in the spring and take care of them from then on than getting them shipped during the season.

So now I have to decide.... do I stick with the Whitespire that I bought, or wait another year and buy a clumping one next spring and call to cancel the tree that I bought?? The single-trunk tree IS pretty..... but it's not cheap!! And it's not like I can return it a couple of weeks after it's delivered if I decide I don't want it!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
jan in van's picture
jan in van

Good for you for waiting. I started reading the post and then noticed the 2006 date. Scrolled right to the bottom to see why it was active again. I'm so impatient I never would have waited. You did the right thing.

reno-vator's picture
reno-vator

is we bought the tree, the house came with !

and I couldn't help but include a pic of my pride and joy . . .just got it last year

Dawn's picture
Dawn

Perfect! I think it's good you waited for exactly what you want.

JMac11's picture
JMac11

Great news! I'm sure it was worth the wait to get the exact tree you wanted wasn't it! You'll have to post some pictures once it's in!! :clapping:

smoodgie's picture
smoodgie

Well, I waited a year, and I FINALLY have my clumping Whitespire Birch!! :confetti: I called the nursery yesterday to ask if they had any in stock, and they said they had a couple. So I went to the nursery after work and picked my tree and it's going to be delivered next week. Yay!! :bliss:

It's not normal to be so obsessed over a tree, is it?? :eek:

Inglewood's picture
Inglewood

I just had put in a Crimson Forst Birch this weekend. White bark with red leaves. I had never seen one of these before....looks cool!

smoodgie's picture
smoodgie

Not yet.... but I will, in case somebody else has the tree that I want!! Although I suspect that I may not have much luck -- but I don't know if I don't try, right?!

bigmama's picture
bigmama

Have you checked other places though??

smoodgie's picture
smoodgie

Well, my tree order is cancelled :( :cry: I SO want a birch tree NOW, but I'll wait till I can get exactly what I want. *Sigh* Why do I always have to like what's expensive or unavailable?!?!??!

smoodgie's picture
smoodgie

You're all right...... better to wait and get what I really want. Like you said Mel, it isn't a shurb or a plant -- it's a HUGE TREE!!!!

Yep, itsjustme, that's the kind of birch I want :) I think the tree in the picture has multiple trunks?? I see at least two, I'm pretty sure....

Maybe I'll call around and see if any other garden centres have clumping Whitespires in stock.....

Thanks for helping -- I know cancelling the tree is the best thing to do. I just needed that extra reinforcement to do it!!

Jeep's picture
Jeep

I would wait until next year and get the one I really want or it will always bug you and you'll never be really happy with it.

itsjustme's picture
itsjustme

There is a beautiful birch nearby. Is this the type? I agree with Mel, and wait until you can get what you really want.

Mel76's picture
Mel76

Smoodgie...I know its really really hard to do this..but I think you should WAIT!!! Call and cancel the birch and order the one you want next spring..its not like its a lil tiny flower/shrub of some sort you can just rip up and throw away if you aren't satisfied..a mature tree purchase is a HUGE purchase. So..wait wait wait..sorry.
:) Mel

Comment Guidelines

We welcome your feedback on Houseandhome.com. H&H reserves the right to remove any unsuitable personal remarks made about the bloggers, hosts, homeowners and/or guests we feature. Please keep your comments focused on decorating, design, cooking and other lifestyle topics. Adopt a tone you would be willing to use in person and do not make slanderous remarks or use denigrating language. If you see a comment that you believe violates any of the guidelines outlined above, please click “Alert a Moderator.” Thank you.

OK